A book of admirable urgency and public feeling, but one that too often mistakes uplift for transformation.
Amanda Gorman writes with an instinct for the ceremonial line: the phrase that lifts itself up in the mouth, gathers a crowd, and asks to be remembered. In Call Us What We Carry, that gift is real and often stirring. Her best passages catch grief in motion, turning pandemic loneliness, civic fracture, and historical trauma into images that arrive cleanly and stay with you. She knows how to make a line step forward with confidence, and when the poem allows itself restraint, her work can feel brisk, humane, and genuinely alive.
Yet I found the collection repeatedly pressing upon the same note of exhortation. Gorman is so committed to speaking toward endurance, hope, and collective repair that the poems can begin to sound less discovered than delivered. The language too often reaches for uplift before it has earned complexity; one feels the scaffolding of the message beneath the music. Her rhetorical gifts are abundant, but rhetoric is not enough when it is not tempered by surprise, inwardness, or silence. A poem should sometimes hesitate. Here, many do not.
The book’s pandemic framing gives it coherence, but also a certain monotony. Its collage-like structure and historical allusions aim to widen the field of sorrow, yet the gestures can feel programmatic, as if lyric witness were being repeatedly translated into civic statement. At her weakest, Gorman flattens experience into slogan-adjacent confidence. The danger is not earnestness — earnestness is admirable — but over-composure. Grief, especially communal grief, is messy, uneven, and often inarticulate; the collection is most persuasive when it lets that ugliness remain unresolved.
Still, I do not want to dismiss the book’s ambitions. Gorman is a poet of public address, and there is value in a voice willing to stand in the square and speak plainly when so much contemporary verse turns inward or coy. She has timing, momentum, and an ear for the line that wants to be heard aloud. I admire the discipline behind that performance even when I think the performance itself is too polished for the wounds it describes. Call Us What We Carry is a serious book, but a cautious one; it reaches for witness and often settles for eloquence.
Who should read this
Read it if you want poetry of public feeling, civic grief, and polished oratory. Readers who prefer ambiguity, strangeness, or harder-won lyric complexity may find it too controlled and too intent on uplift.
A personal note from O'Brien
I came away respecting Gorman’s poise more than loving the poems themselves. There are strong lines here, but I kept wishing she would trust fracture, silence, and difficulty a little more.
Conversation(0)
Join in — no account needed. A name and email are all it takes. Your email is never shown publicly.